ASL Grammar: Understanding Sentence Types, Prepositions, and Non-Manual Markers, Study Guides, Projects, Research of English

Download ASL Grammar: Understanding Sentence Types, Prepositions, and Non-Manual Markers and more Study Guides, Projects, Research English in PDF only on Docsity! o Self-Paced Modules for iP SE est iaeed matey Stat G r F m m i) = Minnesota Registry of Interpreters for the Deaf Self-Paced Modules for Educational Interpreter Skill Development These self-paced learning modules are designed to be tools that educational interpreters can use to enhance their skills in pursuit of certification. Successful completion of this module series does not guarantee the interpreter will successfully obtain certification from the National Registry of Interpreters for the Deaf (RID) or any other certifying body, nor does it guarantee employment in an educational setting. Any interpreter working with these modules must understand that the Minnesota RID, RID and/or Minnesota Department of Children, Families and Learning are not responsible for an interpreter's success or failure in taking any national certification test or in his or her pursuit of employment. MRID, 1996 Grammar !Im Equipment and Materials Equipment 4 audio tape recorder/player, .\I VCR and video camera. Materials The following materials are used extensively in this module for demonstration and for practice. Readings: Baker, Charlotte and Dennis Cokely. 1980. American Sign Language: A Teacher's Resource Text on Grammar and Culture. Silver Spring, MD, T. J. Publishers. Humphries, T. and Carol Padden and T.J. O'Rourke. 1980. A ~asic-Course in American Sicn Language. Silver Spring, MD, T. J. Publishers. Valli, Clayton and Ceil Lucas. 1992. Linguistics of American Sicn Language: A Resource Text for ASL Users. Washington, D.C. Gallaudet University Press. Humphrey, Janice and Bob Alcorn. 1995. So You Want To Be An Intermeter. Salem, OR. Sign Enhancers. Videotapes American S i ~ n Langua~e: A Teacher's Resource Text on Grammar and Culture. Part 1 Silver Spring, MD, Sign Media, Inc. American S i ~ n Laneuaee: Student Text-Unitsl-6 and Unit 8. Silver Spring, MD, Sign Media, Inc. Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 MRID Educational Interpreter Grant Project ASL Grammatical Aspects: Comparative Translations. Salem, OR. Sign Enhancers. (Accompanied by workbook and CD-ROM). The Face of ASL Tapes 1-4. Silver Spring, MD, Sign Media, Inc. Valli, Clayton and Ceil Luca. Linguistics of American Sign Language. Videotape. Part Four on Syntax. Washington, D.C. Gallaudet University Press. Valli, Clayton. 1991. The Linguistics of ASL. Waubonsee Community College. Teleconference. 111 Time his module is not intended to be an introduction to ASL grammar. It is the assumption of the authors that you T already have a working knowledge of ASL. This module is intended to give you a review of various grammatical features of ASL. It is hoped that it will also provide you with a framework for incorporating future findings in the field of linguistic research. To that extent this module is a lifelong work. For the immediate future, you should plan to spend two to three weeks going through this module. It is hoped that you will be reexamining your interpreting work on a daily basis and trying to incorporate a variety of new grammatical features. Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 Grammar A. Sentence Types in Enqlish B ecause this module focuses on interpreting from English into ASL, it will be important for you to be able to identify different types of sentences. Identify the following English sentences by placing the letter corresponding with the type in the space provided : Conditional ................... C Yes /No Question ....... YN Wh Question ................. WH Declarative .................. D Negative ......................... N Imperative ................... I Topic-Comment ............ TC 1. I am an interpreter. - 2. That's not the shirt I want. - 3. Dogs? I love dogs! 4. Go to your room! - 5. Are you sick? - 6 . That woman knows me. 7. He doesn't like spinach. 8. Who was the second president of the U.S.? - 9. He bought a Mercedes? - 10. Come over here! 11. How did you get so dirty? 12. If it doesn't rain, the grass will die. 13. Do you think she'll go to Yale if she gets an acting scholarship? Boinis, Gajewski, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 MRID Educational Interpreter Grant Project K Overview and Activities A. General Comments on Language few words need to be said about the dynamic nature of language. All languages are continually changing. In English we create new words almost daily, many of these words are in new and growing fields of technology i.e. computer science, genealogy and aerospace. While our vocabulary is constantly changing, we rarely have a new sentence type. We rarely develop a new way to modify verbs. One new structure that has come to light is the sarcastic response 'NOT!' Saying 'NOT!" effectively negates the aforementioned facts of a sentence. This is hardly a widespread change in the use of our standard negation rules of English. We will probably see this construction fade from usage in a few years. Because English has been studied for many centuries a lot is known about the rules of English. Analysis of spoken languages date back to 1600 B.C. In dramatic contrast, ASL has been studied since 1960, when William Stokoe first published a paper describing ASL as a true, rule-governed language, not just a random system of gestures. Because of the incredibly short amount of time linguists have focused on ASL, we don't know as much about it. Much of what we do know about ASL grammar is still being debated and revised. Some of what you learn in this module may be new information and may be different from what you have previously learned. Try to be open to new observations and discoveries in this field. After you are certified, keep up with ASL research to see what they uncover next! Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 Grammar B. Grammar is... F irst we must begin with a definition of grammar. Grammar is a set of rules that governs a particular language. Every language has its own, unique grammar. While the grammatical rules of ASL may not be obvious to us, they are known by native signers. By applying the appropriate grammatical rules correct ASL sentences are produced. When not followed, unacceptable sentences are created. When we say a person 'knows' a language, we mean that they know and use the grammar of that language. Most of the time this knowledge is subconscious or at the 'gut level.' As native speakers of English, we may not know which rule is being applied, but we have an 'ear' for a correct English sentence. Likewise we are jarred when we hear an ungrammatical sentence. C. Prescriptive vs. Descriptive Grammar inguists who study grammar take two approaches: one prescribes the rules that a language group should be using. For example in English we are taught to say 'John and I went to the store,' not John and me ...' 'I' is the correct pronoun to use in the subject position. Grammar books teach prescriptive grammar. This module will prescribe the correct rules of ASL grammar. We hear people say 'John and me went to the store,' or 'John and myself went to the store' or even 'I went to the store and John came with.' Even though these sentences break the rules of English, we can understand them. Linguists who study how language is actually being used are called descriptive grammarians. Because rules are broken all the time in English and in ASL, you will have to be a keen observer of what forms of language are actually being used. Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 MRID Educational Interpreter Grant Project Non=Manuall Features hen Stokoe first identified the parts of a sign he identified the handshape, movement, and location as w each having a critical role in determining the composition of a sign. Very soon he realized that facial expression was also a key element of some signs. When we use the term 'facial expression' to talk about ASL we mean more than emotional states. All languages use smiles and frowns to help convey meaning but they are not a grammatical part of the language as they are in ASL. Signers generally use the top part of the face, brows and eyes, to convey grammatical information such as sentence type. The lower half of the face, the lips and mouth, have specific sets of movements that provide descriptive information. But facial expression is only part of the features linguists call 'non-manual features.' In other words ASL is more than just what the hands are doing. The non- manual features that accompany certain signs are as important as the hands in conveying meaning. ASL uses non-manual features to a much greater degree than English does. For these reasons you will note that all the modules emphasize attention to facial expressions and other non-manual behaviors: body shifting, head tilts and pausing to name a few. However, this creates a dilemma for writers. It is very difficult to describe facial expression in written English. Since facial expression is not crucial to the comprehension of English, the language doesn't have many ways to talk about facial expression. Because of the limitations of English, we often recommend watching a videotape to observe the facial expression and other non-manual behaviors. This may be frustrating at times but, a picture is worth a thousand words in this case! Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 Grammar I. Declarative A declarative sentence states a fact, it simply puts forth information. Declarative sentences are very common in both ASL and in English. The following are examples of declarative sentences in English: I am an interpreter. John has two dogs. ASL is the fourth most commonly used language in the U.S. When we sign declarative sentences in ASL the word order is Subject-Verb-Object. The accompanying facial grammar is: direct eye contact with addressee head-nod at end of sentence Examples of declarative sentences in ASL: WOMAN SHE KNOW ME I WANT CAR I CAT IT HUNGRY IT (From Humphries, lesson 3 and 4) 2. Imperatives or Commands Imperatives or commands tell the addressee to do something. Examples of imperative sentences in English are: Give him his toy! Go to your room! Sit down and eat! Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 MRID Educational Interpreter Grant Project The command in ASL includes: .I direct eye gaze at addressee, possible frowning absence of the subject sharp, tense movement of the verb or a slow, deliberate movement of the verb to show even more emphasis. Sometimes a sentence can be signed with just the verb. For example: GO!, or SHUT-UP! The subject is indicated through eye contact, or sometimes by using a pronoun after the verb. Imperatives are used infrequently in both languages. Examples of imperatives in ASL: (The symbol * is used to indicate an imperative. To indicate a sign with the eye-gaze directed in a particular direction the symbol- is used.) "SIT* "SHUT-UP-YOU* gaze down, rt *FINISH*YOU TEASE-TO rt CAT, *FINISH*YOU (examples from Baker and Cokely) 3. Negative Negative sentences occur as frequently in ASL as they do in English. Examples of negative sentences in English are: We don't have a dog. I don't know, He doesn't like spinach. I can't remember your name. - - - Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 Grammar Negative sentences in ASL have the following features: R shaking the head from side to side throughout sentence R possible frowning or squinting (eyebrows squeezed together) R optional use of negation term: NOT, NEVER, NONE, CAN'T, DON'T, WON'T, etc. often at the end of the sentence, or verb that incorporates the negative: DON'T-WANT, DON'T-LIKE, DON'T-KNOW The negative sentence in ASL often does not include a separate sign to create the negation. This is quite different from English where we always add a word or more to create a negation. Because of this, you will want to be sure and allow enough processing time so you are not fooled by a sentence like: "To create new jobs while maintaining our current level of production and profit would be impossible." Since the negation occurs at the very end of the sentence you won't have had the negative head shake throughout if you were following the English too closely. More examples of comparative sentences demonstrating the difference in negation between English and ASL are: neg ( is the convention for noting that the facial grammar indicative of negation is occurring while the over lined signs are being produced.-' is used to indicate that the over lined signs are done with the facial grammar indicative of a topicalized sentence - more on that in a while!) Eng: I am not happy. neg ASL: HAPPY, NOT Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 MRID Educational Interpreter Grant Project Eng: I can't go to the movie. t neg ASL: MOVIE, I-GO CAN'T Eng: Do you want milk? t v /n ques. - ASL: MILK, WANT-YOU b. ASL to English This structure: topic-comment, is not used often in spoken English. When an interpreter carries the grammatical structure of ASL into the English interpretation, the speaker sounds more casual and may be perceived as 'talking down' to the audience. Interpreting the meaning of a sentence rather than the grammatical structure will help the interpretation sound more natural. -- Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 Grammar Questions There are two basic question types: those requiring a Yes or No answer and those requesting an answer to a Wh-question. In English we use a rising intonation to ask yes/no questions such as: Are you going to the movies? Is it raining, again? He bought a Mercedes? Notice in the last example, "He bought a Mercedes?" it is only by the rising voice inflection that we signal a question. If we spoke the same words with falling intonation the sentence would be a simple declarative. While voice inflection plays an important role in adding meaning to English words, facial expressions are crucial to determining meaning in ASL. Facial expression is not optional, it is part of the grammatical structure of a sentence. In yes/no questions in ASL, the following occur along with the signs: raised eyebrows, eyes widened head or body tilted forward sometimes the pronoun or the sign glossed as HUH or '???' is added at the end of the sentence the last sign is held longer sometimes the movement of the last sign is repeated Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 MRID Educational Interpreter Grant Project Look at these two sentences in ASL: (frown) nodding ASL: J-0-H-N BECOME ANGRY Eng: Yes, John is really angry. (declarative) 9 ASL: J-0-H-N BECOME ANGRY Eng: Is John angry? (question) (--+s the symbol used to represent the non-manual features listed above that accompany a yes/no question.) As you can see the presence of the appropriate facial grammar is the only thing that changes the meaning of the sentence from a statement to a question. As you will see throughout this module ASL and English both convey the same kinds of information (questions, declaratives, commands, etc.) but often in very different ways. It is important to notice the order of the signs and how they may differ from the order of the words used in English. When interpreting we need to be sure to allow time to hear and process the entire thought before we begin our interpretation. It is also crucial that we use the appropriate non-manual signals as well. These can be a facial expression, a tilt of the head or a body posture. The other kind of question requests specific information such as: who, what, when, where, why, how, etc. These are called Wh-questions. Examples of these kinds of questions in English are: What is your name? When is the last day of school? Who told you about the party? How did you get so dirty? Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 Grammar 6. Rhetorical Questions Rhetorical questions aren't really questions in that we don't expect an answer from the addressee. They provide a way for the speaker/signer to add more detail on a subject. In English we don't use rhetorical questions very much. When we do they sound like: Guess what I got for my birthday? A car! English uses rhetorical questions in certain discourse styles such as preaching or political speaking. For example you could hear a politician say: Why are there no new jobs in our small towns? 1/11 tell you why, it's because of the high taxes! But this would sound unusual during normal conversation. It's more common for English speakers to use other grammatical devices to convey the same information. For example: I got a new car for my birthday. There are no new jobs because of high taxes. You can tell me when we get there. I think Hawaii is where 1/11 go on my next vacation. I'm tired because I studied all night. In ASL rhetorical questions are posed, then answered by the same person. The question word is often held, sometimes with the movement repeated. The non-manual behaviors that accompany the sign are much different than those for wh- questions: brow is raised (not squeezed together as in wh- questions) head is tilted head may shake slightly Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 MRID Educational Interpreter Grant Project Rhetorical questions in ASL are structured so the non-manual behavior occurs only while the question word is signed, followed by a pause then the response. The response is signed with a neutral facial expression. For example: TODAY LUNCH-ME WHERE, CAPITOL 7. Conditional Conditional sentences are common in English and in ASL. They include two parts: the condition and the result. Conditional sentences present an 'if this ..., then that' framework. Here are some examples of conditional sentences in English: 1. If Brian agrees, we will leave at 8. 2. If it doesn't rain, the tomatoes will die. 3.If you want to improve, study hard! 4. If she hates traffic, why does she live in New York? 5. If they serve meat, he won't eat there. 6. If you like stores and rides and restaurants, you will love the Mall of America. Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 Grammar As you can see the condition can be stated in the affirmative as in sentences 1, 3, 4, 5, and 6 or in the negative as in sentence 2. The result can be a statement that is in the affirmative such as sentence 1, 2, and 6, or it can be a negative statement like sentence 5. The result can also be a command like sentence 3, or a question like sentence 4. ASL allows for all these same constructions. In the condition segment the phrase can begin with the sign glossed as SUPPOSE , or the fingerspelled variant of #IF. In either case the conditional part of the sentence MUST be accompanied by the proper non-manual behavior. The facial expression is so important to the conditional type sentence that no manual signal is even necessary. The required facial expression for the conditional part of the sentence is: head moved to side eyebrows raised This facial expression is held throughout the entire condition. The last sign in the condition may be held slightly longer than normal, thus creating a pause between the segments. If the condition is a lengthy one, the head may nod in addition to the above facial expression. The non-manual behaviors that accompany the result part of the sentence depend on what kind of phrase it is. A nod accompanies an affirmative statement, a head shake goes along with a negative statement, etc. See sections F. 1 - 5 do this module for the complete description of the non-manual features. Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 MRID Educational Interpreter Grant Project Prepositions Prepositions are used in English to show relations between objects in a sentence. Maybe you remember the definition of a preposition being: "anything an airplane can do to a cloud" over, under, into, through, on, in, by, etc., etc. For example the following sentences each contain a preposition: The class went to the zoo. The teacher stepped out of the room. There are 15 children on the jungle gym. Her pencil fell under the desk. In addition the words 'of,' 'for' and 'with' are prepositions in English, as they also show relationships. For example: The book of Mary's. Every year we eat cranberries with our turkey. He got a new horn for his bike. Other languages express these ideas in different ways. ASL does not use prepositions the same way English does. This is not to say that an ASL user cannot express the same kinds of relationships, they can. ASL utilizes classifier predicates to represent some of the objects in these kinds of sentences and then uses the signing space to manipulate these objects or indicate how they are interacting. For example: ASL: ROAD BUMPY(CL) CAR-VEHICLE-DRIVE-DOWN (jerkily) Eng.: The car bounced along the rough road. t ASL: TABLE INDEX -rt BOOK CLASSIFIER-PREDICATE-for- BOOK (on) TABLE Eng.: The book is on the table. Interpreters must recognize when a preposition is used in English, and listen until the whole relationship between the objects is established before we begin interpreting. To learn more about classifiers see the module on Classifiers and the module on structuring space. Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 Grammar I, Verbs I. Subject-Object Agreement Verbs This section will address two processes that affect verbs in ASL: subject/object agreement and aspect. In ASL certain verbs move in space to show agreement with the subject and/or the object of a sentence. Early researchers called these 'directional verbs,' but we now know that they move to specific locations that have been previously established specifically as subject and/or object. There are three categories of these kinds of verbs as explained by Valli and Lucas: "1. Simple sentences with agreement verbs and no separate signs for the subject and the object. The gloss of the English sentence I give you. is an example of this structure. The sentence could be signed as follows: GIVE PRO.l PRO. 2 (PRO.l and PRO. 2 represent two locations that have been identified as pronouns. 1 = the first person pronoun I, me, we, or us; 2 = the second person pronoun singular or plural you.) And the structure of the sentence could be described as follows: VERB subject object" That means that the verb can move about in space in a fairly unrestricted way. This structure is used for verbs glossed as: GIVE, ASK-QUESTION, SEND, LOOK, MOVE, FLY, COME, GO, DRIVE, etc. to name a few. A sub-group of these verbs work in the opposite direction: beginning at the object location and moving toward the location that is identified as the subject. Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 MRID Educational Interpreter Grant Project For example the sentence "I choose you," would be signed like this: CHOOSE PR0.2 PRO.l Even though 'I' is the subject, the initial part of the sign agrees with the location identified as 'you.' Another verb in this category is SUMMON. Let's look at the sentence The principal called me to his office. In ASL it would look like: PRINCIPAL SUMMON PRO. 1 PR0.3 The signing of the verb begins in front of the signer's body and moves outward. Even though 'the principal' is the subject of this sentence, the movement of the verb is towards the location previously identified as 'principal.' Other verbs in this category include: INVITE, TAKE-OUT, etc. Again according to Valli and Lucas, a second possible structure is one where: "2. Verbs that allow or require a separate sign for the subject. TELL is one of these verbs, the English sentence, "He tells me," would be signed as follows: PR0.3 TELL pro.1 HE (the third person pronoun) would be represented with the index finger, while the information about the object, me, would be in the location part of the verb." (1992) This structure is used for ASL verbs: TELL, SEE, INFORM, etc. Notice that the production of these signs is anchored on the signers body. Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 Grammar They confirm that not all verbs can be inflected for all aspects, but here is a list of verbs that can inflect for the aspects mentioned above: GO-TO RUN-TO THROW-AT INSULT SEND-TO PREACH-TO PICK-ON MAKE-FUN-OF BLAME ASK-TO HIT GIVE-TO INFORM LOOK-AT TEACH TEASE TTY-CALL TELL-TO FORCE BAWL-OUT BOTHER TELL LIE PLAY WRITE ANALYZE TO-STUDY MEETING Because in English these descriptions of tempera1 aspect can occur at a variety of places in sentences, we must be sure to use enough processing time when interpreting from English to ASL. The interpreter need to hear how an action is performed: with what degree of regularity and with what mental attitude, before deciding how to inflect the verb. Otherwise the interpretation would contain more separate signs and would closely follow English word order. When that happens we are actually transliterating and no longer interpreting. There is new research into how aspect is shown through inflecting verbs in ASL, but little is published. Keep up with current literature for the latest information. Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 MRID Educational Interpreter Grant Project 3. ASL to English When interpreting from ASL to English inflected verbs pose a different challenge. Many interpreters make the mistake of saying something like, "So I watched TV and watched and watched." This sounds awkward to an English speaker and says nothing about how the TV was watched. Work on developing more natural sounding expressions in English; this is a good place to try including idioms in your interpretation. J. A Word About Transliteration hen transliterating these various sentences types and various aspects of verbs, the interpreter follows w English word order more closely. Interpreters still need to incorporate the facial grammar in the upper portion of the face i.e. the sentence type markers, when transliterating. The facial grammar on the lower half of the face may be replaced by mouthing the English source text. Although the word order of a transliterated message may follow English structure, other elements like facial grammar, temporal inflections and the use of space for subject/object agreement will help the visual message be clearer. To see examples of each sentence type transliterated and compared to ASL, watch the Sign Enhancers tape, ASL Grammatical Aspect: Comparative Translations. The RID describes what grammatical features and vocabulary choices should be included in transliteration in the "Report on the National Testing System" (Views, February 1996, pp.24). They are: Use of space for role taking (characterization) Use of space for subject-object agreement and verb inflections Conceptually correct sign choices (based on meaning rather than on form) 11 Some amount of "initialization" but only to the extent that initialization is used by deaf adults (not to the extent of Manual English Codes) Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996 Grammar K. Deaf Language Mentor I n this and other modules we mention the term Deaf Language Mentor. We urge you to establish a working relationship with a Deaf person who can serve as an ASL consultant to you. By discussing grammatical features with a native ASL user you can increase your understanding of the subtle differences between signs. A native signer will also be more likely to use proper non-manual grammar and facial expression, therefore strengthening your overall language skills! The Department of Human Services Deaf and Hard of Hearing Services Division has provided training to some Deaf persons on how to be a language mentor. These mentors understand your goals as an interpreter and are trained to assist you in improving your ASL skills. How Do I get a Deaf Mentor? If you cannot find a trained mentor in your area you could approach a native Deaf signer and see if he or she would be willing to work with you. It would be a good idea to select a Deaf person who attended a residential school or someone who is in contact with other Deaf adults. You may want to post an ad at the local Deaf club or in the RSC's newsletter. Expect to pay this person, they are providing you a valuable service. Or you could barter and offer an exchange of services. Before you begin you will need to discuss your expectations of one another. Talk with each other about what you expect to do, how you plan to meet your goals, and set a beginning and end date for your sessions. What do we do? You could consult your mentor if you have a question about a sentence type or verb inflection. Avoid asking for a direct translation from an English sentence. You will get a more natural response and learn more about the sign if you provide a context for the conversation. Let's say you want to see the non- Boinis, Gajewski Mickelson, Gordon, Krouse, Swabey, 1996