How to brief a case, Study Guides, Projects, Research of Administrative Law

Download How to brief a case and more Study Guides, Projects, Research Administrative Law in PDF only on Docsity! HOW TO BRIEF A CASE The cases that you will read are the written opinions of trial and appellate court judges explaining their decisions in the lawsuit. A court opinion is similar to a short story of an incident in which a court acted to resolve a legal dispute. The opinions are a record of the court’s decisions that will be used as precedents to provide authority or guidance in resolving future legal disputes. Case briefing is an aid in reading and understanding court opinions. The process is actually a very familiar task to you – it involves outlining and making notes about what you read by identifying the parts of a case and summarizing them. Case briefs will be useful to you in preparing for class and in reviewing for exams. After you have read a case, re-read and brief it using the following format for briefing a case. 1. Name of Case Write the name of the case at the beginning of your brief so that you will be able to identify it later. The case name usually contains the names of the plaintiff and the defendant, who are the parties to the lawsuit. Be sure that you can identify who sued and who was sued as you read through the case. 2. Facts Briefly summarize the facts of the case. Facts are the “who, when, what, where, and why” of the case. Describe the history of the dispute, including the events that led to the lawsuit, the legal claims and defenses of each party, and what happened in the trial court. Do not merely copy the facts verbatim; not every detail is important. Instead, include only the relevant facts. To decide which facts are relevant, ask yourself whether a particular fact was important to the court’s decision. If the answer is yes, include that fact in your brief. You can also ask yourself whether the court’s decision may have been different if a particular fact was omitted or changed. If so, then it is important. You should also look for facts that are repeated at least once in the court’s opinion since these tend to be legally relevant. 3. Issue(s) The issue is a statement of the question of law that the court must answer in order to decide which party should win. A case may involve more than one issue. Sometimes the court will directly state the issue in the opinion. If so, then you can quote the court’s statement of the issue in your brief. In most cases, however, you will need to write your own statement of the issue. The issue should be expressed in the form of a question that can be answered “yes” or “no”. To ensure that your issue statements are written in the form of a question, begin them with “whether,” “did,” “can,” “does,” “is,” etc. 4. Holding(s) The holding is the answer to the issue. If there are multiple issues, then you should state a holding for each issue. The holding succinctly states the court’s ultimate conclusion, but does not fully explain the conclusion. Write the holding as a single sentence that begins with “yes” or “no,” followed by the word “because.” Doing this will ensure that you directly answer the issue and provide a brief reason for the court’s conclusion. 5. Rationale The court must justify its holding by providing reasons for answering the issue in the way that it did. The rationale is a summary of the reasons that explain how the court reached its decision. The goal for this part of your brief is to understand how the court used the rules of law to resolve the dispute. The court will state the applicable rules of law, and they can be found in readings from your textbook as well. You should summarize how the court applied the rules to the facts to reach its conclusions. After you have finished briefing a case, take a moment to critically evaluate the court’s decision. Ask yourself whether you agree with the outcome. Is the outcome fair in light of the facts and the law? Has the court considered all of the relevant facts? Do you agree with the court’s reasoning? What is the likely impact of the decision in the business environment? There are different approaches to briefing each aspect of the case that work equally well. You can write your brief in narrative form or simply list the facts, issues, holdings, and reasons as bullet points in your brief. The key is to create a complete summary of the court’s opinion. Remember also: case briefs should be brief. A good rule of thumb is no more than one page for most cases. To practice briefing a case using the method described above, read the following case of Hagan v. Adams Property Associates, Inc. The case involves a limited liability company, or LLC, which is a type of business where the owners manage the business but have limited legal liability as to business debts and obligations. After you have read the Hagan case, re-read it while referring to the sample case brief that follows. As you do so, critically evaluate the outcome of the case and the reasoning behind the court’s decision. Consider whether or not you agree with the court’s decision.