Comparing Distributed System Design Proposals, Study Guides, Projects, Research of Computer Science

Download Comparing Distributed System Design Proposals and more Study Guides, Projects, Research Computer Science in PDF only on Docsity! Team: Prasad Saripalli, Jeremiah Blanchard & Saurin Desai Proposal Review Table: In order to keep the overall discussion brief the tabular format is adopted and pros and cons are mentioned here for each of the proposals reviewed. No. Name of the document Pros Cons Score 1 Bhavyan.pdf 1) No new commands needed. 2) Unique BFS tree approach is nice to trickle down the information and easy to maintain though a little more implementation detail would have helped. 1) How to join a new group? 2) Definition of neighbor can be relative since no criteria are mentioned on what defines a neighbor 3) Maintaining two lists will add overhead. 4) Resources would be consumed in information retrieval. 5) No message and command syntax defined other than server discovery protocol. 4 2 Jindal.pdf 1) Implementation Directory service approach is included for server discovery which create a centralized repository for information lookup. 1) How to maintain the directory service and how many replicas are needed on the overall network? 2) Maximum number of multicast address needs to be defined. 3) Fault tolerance system needs thorough implementation details. 4.5 3. Boada.pdf 1) Simple implementation. 2) Reuse of the project2 details. 1) Too many parameters in each commands. 2) Large overhead 3) Message syntax confusing 4.5 4. Brian.pdf None? Very short on detail 1 5. Dube.pdf 1) Detailed documentation 2) All features including fault tolerance designed well. 2) Complicated design; may be difficult to implement. 4 6. Dugan.pdf Detailed, easy-to-read Could use more 4