case study state liabiility practica admin II, Ejercicios de Derecho Administrativo

¡Descarga case study state liabiility practica admin II y más Ejercicios en PDF de Derecho Administrativo solo en Docsity! Case i State liability After having read the Judgments of the Spanish Supreme Court (Third Chamber) of 19 June 1998 (appeal 1985/1994) and 30 May 2006 (appeal 211/2005), please answer the following questions: 1. Which conditions must be met for the Public Administrations to be liable under Spanish Law? 2. When inmates commit suicide, why the State is liable in some cases but not in others? 3. Is State liability always really strict under Spanish law? After having read the Judgment of the Spanish Supreme Court (Third Chamber) of 15 March 2005 (appeal 7498/2000), please answer the following questions: 4. Did the Administration cause the death of the child? Why? 5. Did the Administration act negligently? Why? Did the mother of the child act negligently? Why? Does the negligence of the victim exclude State liability? 6. Let us suppose that the death of the child was caused by another woman attending the talk, who took out a gun she had hidden in her handbag and fired several shots at the participants. Would the State be liable in such case?